The phrase I hear most often in my clinical practice is this: I don’t know who I am.
People seek out therapy for all kinds of reasons, but sooner or later, some version of that sentence finds its way into the room. My clients might express an inability to make decisions, often ruminating over what’s right and wrong. Many describe a lack of agency or feel as if they don’t have a voice. Some say to me, “I didn’t have a horrible childhood. There wasn’t some life-altering event, so why am I not happy?” Regardless of what motivates them to seek help, the common thread is a disconnection between who they know they could be and how they currently live.
Somewhere along the way, these clients started leading from a place that pleases others or protects the most vulnerable parts of them. It may have developed slowly, from parents who only gave affirmation based on performance or from years of adapting to cultural norms, or all at once, from an acute traumatic event that altered how they experienced the world. Those experiences are what I call imprints, and they come in two kinds, gradual and acute.
When they talk about who they’ve become, they describe emotions, thoughts, and sensations they don’t understand, which makes it harder for them to soothe themselves. As a clinician, I work with all of those things, but none of them encompass who a person is. Although modern psychology has given us incredible techniques to work with the many aspects of the mind and body, it doesn’t define the place we’re guiding people back to. I believe that place is the soul. Across more than 30 years as a licensed marriage and family therapist, helping my clients differentiate between leading from those adaptive parts and leading from their center—or soul—has become my life’s work.
An Old Story
My journey to becoming a therapist began after university, when I moved to Vienna, Austria, to work with Young Life, a faith-based nonprofit organization focused on mentoring adolescents. The organization allowed employees to do postgraduate studies in theology through Fuller Theological Seminary alongside the job, and I jumped at the opportunity. It was at this time that I met my now-husband, Craig. I have to acknowledge my husband in my clinical story because without him, I would’ve never pursued this career.
I grew up in Washington, DC, in an extremely academic family. My father was a highly regarded lawyer, and my siblings thrived in school. I was the youngest, and I had severe learning disabilities. Year after year, the school system told me in one way or another that my brain didn’t work the way it was supposed to. So I adapted. I learned to read people and connect quickly. I was always the fun one. I relied on my intuition to survive socially and emotionally, and I chose it over my academic ability, the part of me I’d been told wasn’t enough. Years later, I’d recognize the same pattern in my clients: a limiting belief formed early, and the adaptations we build around it until we mistake them for who we are.
Craig immediately saw me differently. When I opened up to him about my academic struggles, he looked at me in disbelief. He said, “Cheryl, you’re so smart. You just need an editor.” He didn’t mean someone to edit my writing, but someone who could come alongside me and help me turn the way my brain worked into something I could share. It seems like a simple exchange, but it was the first time in my young adult life that someone looked past the parts of me I’d developed to survive and saw me as capable and whole.
To Craig, the belief that I wasn’t smart enough was an old story, not who I was, and his awareness of my essence made me aware of it, too. We all need people who can look past our parts and recognize us for who we truly are. This is what I do with my clients every day. With his reminder of who I was beyond those beliefs, I began to lead from a more courageous place, asking myself what I truly wanted instead of limiting myself to the story I’d developed inside my head.
On Young Life staff, I quickly observed how teenage girls, most of whom had moved due to a parent’s job relocation, struggled not only with the transition itself but with self-esteem. I noticed how profoundly the move had strained their families. I could support each girl individually, but I couldn’t create the impact I knew was possible because I wasn’t approaching it systemically. I knew I needed further education, and supported by the updraft of Craig’s belief in me, I earned my master’s in clinical psychology at Wheaton College.
My career has taken me to nearly every level of care: day hospitals, inpatient units, schools, and private practice. I’ve sat with survivors of sexual abuse and suicide attempts, with couples on the edge of divorce, and with adolescents stuck in loops of anxiety. I’ve worked with veterans coming home from war, many of them carrying what our field now calls moral injury. When I worked in a psychiatric hospital, I noticed how often patients in acute crisis spoke about God and what they framed as a battle between good and evil. Again and again, my clients showed me that these two worlds—psychology and spirituality, which are sometimes treated as incompatible—weren’t as separate as they seemed.
Before long, people sought me out because I made space for conversations about both. Not every client wanted to speak about spirituality, a choice I always respected. No one should be pushed to. But many did.
In fact, the word psychotherapy can be translated, quite literally, as “care of the soul.” It comes from the Greek psychē, meaning soul, spirit, life, or mind, and therapeia, meaning care, treatment, or healing.
We tend to understand the psyche primarily as the mind: our thoughts, emotions, behaviors, and inner psychological life. But its original intended meaning was much broader. Psychē referred to the animated essence of a human being, the thing that makes us vitally who we are. Long before and far beyond Greek philosophy however, traditions around the world developed their own language for it: the Hebrew nefesh and ruach, the Christian soul, the Islamic ruh and nafs, the Hindu atman, and many others.
Today, the word can be found across modern culture. We call someone our soulmate. Music can be soulful. If you’ve ever spoken to a 20-something in their first corporate job, you’ve no doubt heard, “This job is killing my soul.” And when journalists report on tragedies, they often refer to the “souls lost.” They’re not endowing those lives with religious affiliation; rather, they’re recognizing their dignity. That’s how I feel about the word soul. It captures the inherent dignity of human life.
As a clinician, I’ve come to define soul as the essence of who we truly are, where we find our deepest joy and peace, and our connection to something larger than ourselves. Whatever our clients call it, this is the place I believe we’re guiding them back to.
The Soul vs. the Imprinted Self
When I was two decades into my clinical work, a young mother was referred to me. The family had briefed me on the case before our first session. My client was a mother of three: two toddlers and a new baby. One day, while she was caring for the baby at home, one of her toddlers wandered out to the pool and drowned. It happened in a matter of moments, the way these tragedies so often do.
When she stepped into my office, I can only describe what came in with her as a heaviness. She moved slowly and couldn’t make eye contact with me. She slumped into the couch when she sat. She looked raw, as if she could barely get out of bed. There’s a phrase, “the dark night of the soul,” that comes from the writings of the 16th-century Spanish mystic St. John of the Cross. His poem describes a journey through a dark place where what once gave us meaning and orientation falls away—but the darkness is not the end of the journey. He describes how when you move through it, you emerge transformed, with a deeper understanding of yourself and your relationship to something greater than you.
That is what I felt when this young mother and I began our work together. Her soul was in complete darkness. I knew my work as a clinician would be to travel with her through the darkness she was experiencing and, over time, help her find her way back to herself.
I watched her move through the same psychological cycle over and over again. Slowly, we’d begin to approach what had happened through how it had affected her life. She’d find the courage to name an emotion, to speak about her experience, to allow herself to feel something she’d been unable to touch before. Although brief, these moments were cathartic. She’d return the following week, believing she’d worked through it and that everything could be put behind her. And then I’d watch her protective strategies resurface.
One session, she told me she’d found a local baby who was up for adoption. She was going to adopt the baby, she said, and somehow this would heal the wound. The following week, she came back sobbing. She looked at me and said, “How could I have thought another baby could replace my child?” The shame flooded back in, and the cycle began again.
What my client had experienced was what I call an acute imprint. An imprint is a significant experience that shapes how we understand ourselves, other people and the world around us. Sometimes an imprint happens in a single, life-altering moment, as it did for her. Others form gradually, through layers of experiences that teach us how we need to adapt in order to survive, belong, or feel safe.
Richard Schwartz, the founder of Internal Family Systems, has had a major influence on how I work. I see imprints as the underlying experiences that cause our parts to develop, so beneath the parts and beliefs we form, I look for the imprint, the experience they grew out of. And where Schwartz speaks of the Self, I speak of the soul. Both account for the true essence of a person, but for me, the soul also holds our connection to something larger than ourselves.
Over time, our imprints can eclipse the soul because we begin to identify with the beliefs and emotions that form from them. For this mother, the loss of her child had become inseparable from how she understood herself. She didn’t simply believe she’d made a mistake with unbearable consequences; she believed she was unforgivable. She began to believe she didn’t deserve to be a mother at all. She began to identify with, and lead from, that imprint. This is why I believe so many clients express that deep misalignment from their true nature. They’re living from a protective and reactive place. My client never lost her soul. She just could no longer access it beneath the weight of her grief and shame. The imprint had eclipsed it.
One stigma that still shadows treatment for mental health issues is the idea that you go to therapy when something is “wrong” with you. Yet the adaptations we make to protect our soul always serve a purpose. They protect us until we’re able to integrate them, accept reality and move forward with a greater understanding of who we are. Our worst experiences can also be the most expansive.
Much of my work with this client happened in the chasm between who she believed she had become and who she truly was. Session after session, I bore witness to her essence, her inherent value, and her dignity, until she could become conscious of them herself and begin to return to that place.
We created a container for her feelings, a place where we could take them out and look at them together, so they didn’t have to be all of her, and she could see that what she was carrying was something we could work through, at her own pace. I remember one session when she looked at me hopelessly and said, “I feel like I’m unforgivable. God will never forgive me.” I said, “But that’s not God. That’s your voice.” She realized then that she had been projecting her own fears onto God, and that the voice condemning her was her own.
After a few years of working together and meeting weekly, my client went on to welcome another child into the world. She’d shifted this belief of being unforgivable and undeserving into the deep knowing that she was inherently good, that she could be forgiven, and that she was worthy of being a mother. I supported her as she separated her identity from what had happened, and developed tools with her to navigate the grief as it continued to come up in waves.
When people speak from the soul, the same qualities keep showing up: clarity, compassion for themselves and others, connectedness, and the courage to do hard things, much like the eight Cs of Self that Schwartz describes. When an imprint is speaking, I hear fear and shame instead. Sometimes I even hear both in the same sentence: “I know the right thing to do, but I can’t do it.” The first half of that sentence comes from the soul, and the second half is the imprint talking.
Other imprints form slowly, from messages we hear in childhood. One client of mine was a lifelong people-pleaser whose anxious mother passed that anxiety down to her without ever giving her the tools to manage it, the way generational trauma so often moves through a family. Our job as clinicians is to help clients locate the voice of the soul within them, tell it apart from the imprint, and, over time, let it become the dominant voice. Learning to differentiate between those voices is, to me, the heart of integrating the soul into clinical practice.
Questions that Point to the Soul
In my practice, I ask clients questions that point them toward reconnecting with the soul. When was the last time you made a courageous decision? When was the last time you acted with compassion, toward yourself and others? When did you last feel deeply calm, or make a decision from a place of clarity? I ask when they experience awe. Is it at the theater, at a dinner gathering with friends, while reading a certain book, or while traveling? Their answers always come quickly.
Some clients describe clarity around decisions they’ve made, like taking a job or setting a clear boundary with family. Others remember the courage it took to say something difficult to a spouse, a boss, or a friend, or to stand up for themselves. Parents often describe moments of compassion and patience with their kids. Many say they always feel calm when they’re out in nature, by the water, or with their dog. Because so many of us overfocus on what we do wrong and overlook what we do right, we explore those moments together: what they were doing, who they were with, how it felt, and where it lives in their bodies.
I’ve found that very few clients find questions that point toward the soul foreign or unusual, and the research may suggest why. In 2025, the Pew Research Center published one of the largest studies on religious life in America, surveying more than 36,000 U.S. adults. It found that 86% of Americans believe human beings have a soul or spirit in addition to the physical body, and 79% believe there is something spiritual beyond the natural world, even if we cannot see it. These beliefs extend well beyond traditionally religious Americans. Among those who describe their religion as “nothing in particular,” 79% believe human beings have a soul. So do 67% of agnostics. And a separate, smaller 2024 Pew survey found that even 31% of atheists believe people have a soul or spirt.
The soul will look different for every client. Everyone operates under their own spiritual framework, whether they name it that way or not. Even being an atheist is a spiritual framework worth exploring. Nobody is neutral when it comes to the spiritual realm. Some clients will call that deeper place within them the soul; others, the spirit, the true self or their core. I love the word soul, but therapeutically, I’m not beholden to it. I always ask what word my client would use and how they would describe that place, and if that word doesn’t resonate, we find a different one. Our job is to explore that space alongside them without imposing our own beliefs.
I often find myself returning to St. John of the Cross and his 16th-century poem “Dark Night,” especially when I’m sitting with a client in the middle of their own dark night. In the poem, every outer light is gone, and he is guided only by “the one that burned in my heart,” a light that leads him more surely than the noonday sun. That’s what I see in my clients: in their darkest moments, the way forward doesn’t come from their circumstances but from within. I believe our role as clinicians is to walk alongside clients through that darkness as we help them shed light on their imprints, so they can find that inner light and let it lead them back to themselves.
Our clients are more than their cognitions and physical sensations. The exploration of the soul has existed throughout human history, and I don’t claim to know exactly what the soul is or to have answers to the mysteries that human beings have been exploring for thousands of years. I just believe it’s time we make more room for those questions in clinical practice. If we want to understand the whole person, we need to be willing to look at them through all three dimensions: mind, body, and soul.
Cheryl Donaldson
Cheryl Donaldson, MA, LMFT, LCPC, is a marriage and family therapist and author of the guided journal Lead from Your Soul with more than 30 years of clinical experience across inpatient units, day hospitals, schools, and private practice. She holds a master’s in clinical psychology from Wheaton College and studied theology at Fuller Theological Seminary. Her private practice is based between Charleston, South Carolina, and London. A global lecturer on mental health–informed leadership, she’s given keynotes at the Oxford Master Series, Duke Law School, and Northwestern. Contact: cheryldonaldson.com.